Services that meet the needs of elderly individuals are increasingly provided outside institutional frameworks, with a special focus on improving the quality of life and social inclusion of older adults in the community. This study investigates the needs of elderly people in the municipality of Orebić from the perspectives of both the seniors themselves and the service providers, with a particular emphasis on the need for a day care center. The aim of the research was to gain insight into the needs of elderly individuals and to analyze how a day care center can address those needs. The research was conducted using semi-structured interviews with a sample of nine respondents—six elderly individuals and three service providers. The results showed that older adults express a strong need for social interaction, communal spaces, organized activities, and support, as well as an interest in nursing home services. Experts highlighted very similar needs and pointed to the importance of a day care center as a solution for reducing social isolation and improving the quality of life for older adults. The main challenges identified include a lack of adequate infrastructure and support from local authorities. Despite this, the research results indicate that the introduction of a day care center would significantly contribute to reducing social isolation and enhancing the well-being of elderly individuals in the municipality of Orebić.