Title EVOLUCIJA SIGURNOSNE POLITIKE EUROPSKE UNIJE OD 1999. DO 2015. GODINE: UTJECAJ TERORISTIČKIH NAPADA NA OBLIKOVANJE PROTUTERORISTIČKE POLITIKE
Title (english) THE EVOLUTION OF THE EU SECURITY POLICY FROM 1999 TO 2015: THE IMPACTS OF TERRORIST ATTACKS ON COUNTERTERRORISM POLICY
Author Aleksandra Grubić
Mentor Ksenija Butorac (mentor)
Committee member Robert Mikac (predsjednik povjerenstva)
Committee member Siniša Tatalović (član povjerenstva)
Committee member Irena Cajner-Mraović (član povjerenstva)
Granter University of Zagreb The Faculty of Political Science (Department of International Relations and Security Studies) Zagreb
Defense date and country 2018-10-11, Croatia
Scientific / art field, discipline and subdiscipline SOCIAL SCIENCES Political Science International Relations and National Security
Universal decimal classification (UDC ) 327 - International relations. World, global politics. International affairs. Foreign policy
Abstract Sve učestaliji teroristički napadi i proces radikalizacije stvorili su percepciju terorizma kao ugroze najviše sigurnosne razine u EU-u. Iako je ovaj proces doveo do ubrzanog razvoja protuterorističke politike EU-a, empirijska istraživanja na ovom području ostaju sporadična i segmentirana. Cilj ove disertacije je ustanoviti i na novim osnovama analizirati zakonitosti u promjenama obrazaca odgovora protuterorističke politike EU-a, nadograditi postojeći korpus empirijskih spoznaja i teorijskih postavki te, u konačnici, dati doprinos razumijevanju evolucije i izradi politike borbe protiv terorizma. Predmetno istraživanje je provedeno kvalitativnom analizom sadržaja službenih dokumenata EU institucija uključenih u borbu protiv terorizma u razdoblju od 1999. godine do kraja lipnja 2016. godine. Ovaj postupak obuhvatio je identificiranje i kodiranje ključnih riječi, izraza i sintagmi koji oblikuju borbu protiv terorizma u svrhu objašnjenja načina na koji je oblikovana teroristička prijetnja EU-u te mogućnosti odgovora na ove prijetnje. Rezultati pokazuju kako su visokoprofilirani teroristički napadi počinjeni 2001. godine u SAD-u, 2004. i 2005. godine u Madridu i Londonu te 2015. i 2016. godine u Parizu i Bruxellesu imali ključan utjecaj na stvaranje tri specifična problemska razdoblja u okviru kojih se institucionalizirala protuteroristička politika EU-a. Unatoč tome što se još uvijek ne može govoriti o samostalnoj protuterorističkoj politici na razini EU-a, borba protiv terorizma, sa svakim sljedećim napadom i popratnim fenomenima kao potencijalnim prijetnjama, produbljuje se u smjeru daljnje institucionalizacije koju s vremenom postaje sve teže preusmjeriti jer trošak odumiranja postojećih institucija, agencija ili uvedenih mjera postaje previsok. Rezultati ove studije, također, ukazuju da su jačanju procesa institucionalizacije pridonijeli ne samo teroristički napadi kao kritične točke, nego i strani borci, djelovanje terorističkih organizacija Al Qa’ide i tzv. Islamske države te neregularni priljev imigranata na vanjskim granicama EU-a kao neuralgične točke. Uz navedeno, određeni endogeni faktori poput otvorenih granica, ekonomskog rasta i demokratskog društva u okviru kojeg se potiče integracija i zaštita temeljnih ljudskih prava, kao i korištenje interneta u terorističke svrhe, također su utjecali na postupnu institucionalizaciju protuterorističke politike. Istraživanje je, također, pokazalo kako je većina identificiranih prijetnji na razini Europske unije primarno vezana uz muslimansko društvo, te da manji broj visokorazvijenih država, u kojima su počinjeni teroristički napadi, kontrolira i usmjerava borbu protiv terorizma na razini cijele Europske unije.
Abstract (english) The EU's common counterterrorism policy as well as its active role in the fight against terrorism, has emerged as an answer to the more frequent high profile terrorist attacks and increased radicalisation. Even though, the EU has been faced with terrorist attacks since the 1960’s, these more recent events have created the perception of terrorism as the highest level security threat in the EU. This process has led to a rapid development of counterterrorism policy at the EU level. However, empirical research in this area remains sporadic and fragmented.
The rationale of this research is to identify and analyse changes in the EU counterterrorism patterns based on the new findings, upgrade the existing corpus of empirical knowledge, examine and reassess theoretical concepts and finally contribute to the understanding of the EU security policy. The research is based on the qualitative content analysis of the EU official documents pertaining to the fight against terrorism. It is related to the EU counterterrorism policy in the period of January 1999 to June 2016. The methodology involves a process of identifying and coding key words, expressions and syntagmas for the purpose of abstraction and acquiring of categories and EU counterterrorism policy patterns. A corpus of 278 documents that shapes the fight against terrorism and the EU security policy was used as a representative sample and analysed further. This process was beneficial for explaining the ways in which the EU counterterrorism policy was formed, and it also provided possible answers for fighting these threats. NVivo software was used to support qualitative content analysis by assisting in organising and reporting on a substantive amount of empirical data.
Results demonstrate that high profile attacks committed in USA in 2001, in Madrid and London in 2004 and 2005, and in Paris and Bruxelles in 2015 and 2016 have had a critical influence on the creation of three problem periods within which the EU counterterrorism policy has been institutionalised. The EU counterterrorism policy is being further enhanced and institutionalised after every high-profile terrorist attack. It has been demonstrated that new phenomena such as foreign fighters, terrorist organisations such as Al Qa'ida and ISIS, and irregular immigration on the EU borders also serve as catalysts of institutionalisation. Furthermore, certain endogenous factors like the EU open borders, economic growth, democracy, as well as the amplified use of internet, have additionally influenced the gradual institutionalisation of this policy. On the basis of the results, it could be argued that most threats identified in the documents are primarily associated with the Muslim society. Despite
the fact the attacks were committed in a relatively small number of EU member states, they control and steer the fight against terrorism on the EU level.
Findings in this research point to the fact that the EU counterterrorism policy has evolved gradually from using „soft“ towards “smart” or „hybrid“ power, which implies innovative combination of the elements of „soft“ and „hard“ power. However, it is not enough to observe the evolution of counterterrorism policy only in the spectrum of power. Results demonstrate how the Paris school concept of securitisation can be applied as this process rests on the mundane bureaucratic decisions of everyday politics that manifest itself by introducing new, restrictive measures as well as the instruments following high profile terrorist attacks. Although these preventative measures are directed towards further enhancement of security, they are relatively inadequately coordinated with the protection of the basic values upon which the EU was built. The analysis has demonstrated that in the areas of coordination, cooperation and integration, the EU has managed to impose itself as a significant actor, however the member states remain still polycentric, key actors regarding their national security.
This research has been based on parameters, such as the number and categories of documents that have not been used in the existing research and studies so far. Also, the analysis included a recent period that was marked by rising radicalisation and the escalation of high profile terrorist attacks. The grounds for a thorough insight into the institutionalisation construction of the fight against terrorism has been created in the official EU documents. In conclusion, existing knowledge of the EU counterterrorism policy evolution has been broadened by the reassessment of the existing empirical studies and theories. This has enabled the understanding of the development, efficiency and future development patterns of the EU counterterrorism policy.
Keywords
Europska unija
protuteroristička politika
teroristički napadi
institucionalizacija
borba protiv terorizma
Keywords (english)
European Union
counterterrorism policy
terrorist attacks
institutionalisation
fight against terrorism
Language croatian
URN:NBN urn:nbn:hr:114:982588
Study programme Title: Political Science - doctoral study programme Study programme type: university Study level: postgraduate Academic / professional title: DOKTOR/DOKTORICA ZNANOSTI, PODRUČJE DRUŠTVENIH ZNANOSTI, POLJE POLITOLOGIJA (DOKTOR/DOKTORICA ZNANOSTI, PODRUČJE DRUŠTVENIH ZNANOSTI, POLJE POLITOLOGIJA)
Type of resource Text
Extent 244 str. ; 32 cm
File origin Born digital
Access conditions Access restricted to students and staff of home institution
Terms of use
Created on 2018-10-16 07:56:50